From 0ed964c8a55bbcb94108798e415e31b470789e2a Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: David Oberhollenzer Date: Wed, 22 Aug 2018 00:43:11 +0200 Subject: [PATCH] Cleanup and update documentation Signed-off-by: David Oberhollenzer --- README.md | 71 +++++++++++------ docs/bootup.md | 74 ------------------ docs/cmdline.md | 43 +++++++++++ docs/defconfig.md | 106 +++++++++++++++++++++++++ docs/init.md | 71 +++++++++++++++++ docs/network.md | 83 ++++++++++++++++++++ docs/services.md | 193 +++++++++++++++++++++++++++++----------------- docs/usyslogd.md | 94 ++++++++++++++++++++++ 8 files changed, 568 insertions(+), 167 deletions(-) delete mode 100644 docs/bootup.md create mode 100644 docs/cmdline.md create mode 100644 docs/defconfig.md create mode 100644 docs/init.md create mode 100644 docs/network.md create mode 100644 docs/usyslogd.md diff --git a/README.md b/README.md index a944831..c36ea8b 100644 --- a/README.md +++ b/README.md @@ -1,43 +1,66 @@ # About -This directory contains the source code for a tiny init devised for -the Pygos system. +This directory contains the source code for a tiny service supervision +framework devised for the Pygos system, consisting of an init daemon, +a small syslog daemon and various command line utilities. -The main goal of this project is to create a simple framework for: - -- system boot up and initialization -- service supervision - -With the additional aims of having something that: - -- simply works -- is easy to understand -- is easy to configure and maintain +The individual parts of the framework are designed to be independent of +each other (for instance, the tiny syslogd is intended to work with *any* +init system and other components of the framework don't depend on the presence +of this *specific* syslog implementation) and everything that is not strictly +part of the init system (such as the syslog daemon) can be disabled through +the configure script. -The init process is intended to run on top of Linux and makes use of some -Linux specific features (e.g. signalfd), but if sufficient interest exists, -it should still be possible to make it run on some BSDs or whatever else. +The programs of this package are developed first and foremost for GNU/Linux +systems, so there are some GNU and some Linux extensions used and some of the +code may unintentionally rely on Linux specific behavior. + +Nevertheless, if sufficient interest exists, it should be possible to make it +run on BSDs or other Unix-like systems, but some effort may be required. + The init system tries to mimic the concept of unit files from systemd as those were considered to be a good design choice. -Those parameterizeable service description files are stored in `/usr/share/init` -by default. Services are enabled by creating a symlink in `/etc/init.d`. This -can be done using the `service` command line tool. +In a typical setup, the parameterizeable service description files are stored +in `/usr/share/init` by default. Services are enabled by creating a symlink +in `/etc/init.d`. This can be done more conveniently using the `service` +command line tool. -See [docs/services.md](docs/services.md) for more information on service -description files. -See [docs/bootup.md](docs/bootup.md) for more information on what the init -daemon does during system boot. +A default setup is provided, as needed for the Pygos system, including helper +scripts for setting up mount points and for network configuration. If you want +to use the init daemon for another system, you may have to toss out or adapt +some of the default configuration and make your own. Right now, the system is in a "basically works" proof of concept stage and needs some more work to become usable. -There are plans for *maybe* *eventually* adding support for Linux name -spaces, seccomp filters and cgroups as needed in the medium future. +There are plans for *maybe* *eventually* adding more fancy features like +support for Linux name spaces, seccomp filters and cgroups or network +back ends for the syslog daemon, but right now, features are added only +when the need arises. + + +See [docs/init.md](docs/init.md) for more information on the design, +implementation and caveats of the init daemon. + +See [docs/cmdline.md](docs/cmdline.md) for an explanation on the available +command line tools. + +See [docs/services.md](docs/services.md) for more information on service +description files. + +See [docs/network.md](docs/network.md) for information on how the network +configuration works. + +See [docs/defconfig.md](docs/defconfig.md) for an explanation on the default +services and configuration provided with this package. + +See [docs/usyslogd.md](docs/usyslogd.md) for details on the tiny syslog +implementation. ## Why diff --git a/docs/bootup.md b/docs/bootup.md deleted file mode 100644 index bd2b80e..0000000 --- a/docs/bootup.md +++ /dev/null @@ -1,74 +0,0 @@ -# System Bootup Process - -## Initial Ram Disk to Rootfs transition - -After mounting the root filesystem, either the kernel or the initial ram disk -startup process is expected to exec the init program from the root filesystem. - -At the current time, there is no support for re-scanning the service files -*yet*, so when init is started, the final configuration in `/etc/init.d` has to -be present. As a result, we currently cannot perform mounting of `/etc/` or -packing init into the initial ram disk and doing the rootfs transition. - -Also, as a result of this, changing the service configuration requires a system -reboot to be effective. - -This _will_ change in the future. - - -## Processing Service Descriptions - -The init process reads service description files from `/etc/init.d` which are -usually symlinks to actual files in `/usr/share/init`. - -The exact locations may be changed through configure flags when compiling init. - -Service files specify a *target* which is basically like a SystemV runlevel and -can be one of the following: - -* boot -* reboot -* shutdown -* ctrlaltdel - -After parsing the configuration files, the init process starts running the -services for the `boot` target in a topological order as determined by their -*before* and *after* dependencies. - -Services can be of one of the following *types*: - -* wait -* once -* respawn - -Services of type `wait` are started exactly once and the init process waits -until they terminate before continuing with other services. - -The type `once` also only runs services once, but immediately continues -starting other services in the mean time without waiting. - -Services of type `respawn` also don't stall the init process and are re-started -whenever they terminate. - -## Service Process Setup - -If a service description contains only a single `exec` line, the init process -forks and then execs the command directly in the child process. - -If the service description contains a `tty` field, the specified device file -is opened in the child process and standard I/O is redirected to it before -calling exec. Also, a new session is created. - - -If a service description contains multiple `exec` lines, the init process forks -off to a single child process that does the same setup as above, and then runs -the command lines sequentially by forking a second time for each one, followed -by an exec in the grand child and a wait in the original child. - -If a single command line returns something other than `EXIT_SUCCESS`, -processing of multiple command lines is immediately stopped and the offending -exit status is returned to init. - - -The init process reads environment variables from `/etc/initd.env`. - diff --git a/docs/cmdline.md b/docs/cmdline.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..c3945ec --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/cmdline.md @@ -0,0 +1,43 @@ +# Available Command Line Tools + +## The service command + +The `service` utility can be used for control and administration of services. + +It is composed of several sub commands run by issuing +`service [arguments..]`. + +Currently available service commands are: + + * enable - enable a service with the given list of arguments. + * disable - disable a service. If the service is parameterized, requires the + same arguments used for enabling, to disable the specific instance of the + service. + * dumpscript - generate an equivalent shell script from the `exec` lines of + a service after applying all parameter substitutions. + * list - list all enabled service. A target can be specified to only list + services for the specified target. + * help - display a short help text and a list of available commands. + + +## shutdown and reboot + +The programs `shudown` and `reboot` can be used to signal to the `init` program +that it should transition to the `shutdown` or `reboot` target respectively. + +The option `-f` or `--force` can be used to by pass the init system entirely +and force a hard reset or power off by directly signalling the kernel. + +Running any one of those programs requires superuser privileges. + + +## syslog + +If the `usyslogd` service is built as part of this package, a program called +`syslog` is built that can be used from the command line to send syslog +messages. + +This can for instance be used to produce log messages from shell scripts. + +The log level, facility and identity string can be specified. +See `syslog --help` for more information. diff --git a/docs/defconfig.md b/docs/defconfig.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..af01375 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/defconfig.md @@ -0,0 +1,106 @@ +# Default Service Configuration + +## Pseudo Services + +The default configuration contains a number of "pseudo services" in the boot +target that don't actually do anything but are merely used as anchors in +service dependencies, i.e. they indicate that some sort of milestone in the +boot sequence has been reached. Everything that is part of that milestone +specifies that it should be run *before* that pseudo service and everything +that requires that this milestone has been reached, specifies that it wants +to run afterwards. + +The pseudo targets are (in the order that they are executed): + + * vfs + + All services that do mount point setup go before this, all service that + depend on the fully mounted rootfs go after this. + + * sysinit + + The system has reached a sane state, i.e. the hostname is set, the system + clock has a sane value, modules and kernel parameters are loaded, some + very basic, fundamental services are running (e.g. syslog). + Everything that is part of that setup process goes between `vfs` and + `sysinit`, everything that requires a sane setup goes *after* `sysinit`. + + * network + + Network configuration is done. All services that do network configuration + should position themselves between `sysinit` and `network`. Everything that + requires a fully configured networking setup should go *after* `network`. + +## Default Bootup Services + +This section outlines the services for the boot target that are enabled by +default. + + +The following services are enabled by default and run *before* the `vfs` target +for filesystem setup: + + * procfs - mount `procfs` to `/proc` and try to mount additional pseudo + filesystems in `/proc` such as `binfmt_misc` + * tmpfs - mount a `tmpfs` to `/tmp` + * sysfs - mount `sysfs` to `/sys` and try to mount additional pseudo + filesystems in `/sys` (e.g. `securityfs`, `configfs`, ...) + * devfs - mount `devtmpfs` to `/dev`, try to mount additional pseudo + filesystems in `/dev` (e.g. `devpts`, `mqueue`, ...) and try to create + some additional device nodes and symlinks. + + +The following services are enabled by default and configured to run *after* +the `vfs` target and *before* the `sysinit` target: + + * hostname - reload hostname `/etc/hostname` + * loopback - bring the loopback device up + * usyslogd - if the `usyslogd` services is compiled with this package, this + service is enabled by default and starts `usyslogd`. + * modules - iterate over the file `/etc/modules` and try to load each module + using modprobe. + * sysctl - restore kernel parameters using `sysctl --system`. See `sysctl(8)` + for a list of possible locations that the parameters are read from. + + +The following services are enabled by default and configured to run *after* +the `sysinit` target and *before* the `network` target: + + * ifcfg - static network configuration + Does the static network configuration outlined in [network.md](network.md) + + +## Default Shutdown and Reboot Services + +For the shutdown and reboot targets, the following services are executed: + + * sigterm - send the SIGTERM signal to all processes and wait for 5 seconds + * sigkill - send the SIGKILL signal to all remaining processes + * ifdown - bring all network interfaces down + * sync - run the sync command + + +## Additional Services not Enabled by Default + + * agetty - A parameterizeable, respawn type `agetty` service. The first + parameter is the terminal device that the getty should run on. + * dhcpcdmaster - If one or more network interfaces should be configured using + dhcpcd, this service starts a central `dhcpcd` master instance. + * dhcpcd - A parameterizeable single shot service that signals the `dhcpcd` + master that it should configure a specific interface. The first parameter + is the interface that should be configured by `dhcpcd`. + * dnsmasq - A respawn type service for the `dnsmasq` DNS and DHCP server. + * hostapd - If the system should operate a WIFI access point, this respawn + type service can be enabled to manage an instace of the `hostapd` program. + * unbound - A respawn type service that manages an instance of the `unbound` + name resolver. + * usyslogd - A respawn type service that manages an instance of the `usyslogd` + syslogd implementation that is part of this package. + * hwclock - If the system has a hardware clock, this service can restore the + kernels clock from the hardware at bootup, between the `vfs` and `sysinit` + targets. + * nft - If enabled, restores net filter table rules during boot. + * swclock - For systems that don't have a hardware clock, this service + restores a somewhat usable time from a file during boot. + * swclocksave - For systems that don't have a hardware clock, this service + saves the current time to a file during shutdown or reboot. diff --git a/docs/init.md b/docs/init.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e76a4b4 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/init.md @@ -0,0 +1,71 @@ +# The Init Daemon + +## Initial Ram Disk to Rootfs transition + +After mounting the root filesystem, either the kernel or the initial ram disk +startup process is expected to exec the init program from the root filesystem. + +At the current time, there is no support for re-scanning the service files +*yet*, so when init is started, the final configuration in `/etc/init.d` has to +be present. As a result, we currently cannot perform mounting of `/etc/` or +packing init into the initial ram disk and doing the rootfs transition. + +Also, as a result of this, changing the service configuration requires a system +reboot to be effective. + +This _will_ change in the future. + + +## Service Types and Targets + +A service file has a *type*, specifying whether the service should be run once +or restarted when it terminates and a *target*, specifying when the service +should be run. + +The *target* is similar to a runlevel in System V init. The init daemon +currently knows about the following targets: + +* boot +* reboot +* shutdown + +When `init` is run, it starts all the services for the `boot` target. From the +`boot` target it can transition to any other target and execute the services +for the specified target. + +The `reboot` and `shutdown` targets cannot transition to any other target and +when invoked, cause initd to drop everything else it intended to do. + +For the `reboot` and `shutdown` targets, respawn type processes are no longer +restarted when they terminate and once all services have been executed, the +`init` program performs a hard system reboot or power off. + +The init program tries to capture the `CTRL+ALT+DELETE` key sequence (or its +local equivalent) and transitions to the reboot target if pressed. + + +## Service Configuration Rescan + +TBD + + +## Control Socket and Signals + +The `init` program catches the following signals: + +* `SIGCHLD` +* `SIGINT` +* `SIGTERM` + +The `SIGCHLD` handler implements standard process reaping. If a terminated +process belongs to one of the supervised services, the configured action is +taken (e.g. restarting it). + +When `SIGINT` is caugth, `init` transitions to the `reboot` target. Similarly, +`SIGTERM` causes `init` to transition to the `shutdown` target. + + +For more complex tasks, `init` creates a control socket that the command line +tools included in this package can use. For the time being, the control socket +can only tell the init daemon to transition to the `reboot` or `shutdown` +target. diff --git a/docs/network.md b/docs/network.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..f111a8f --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/network.md @@ -0,0 +1,83 @@ +# Static Network Configuration + +The default configuration provides multiple services that perform network +initialization and static configuration using helper scripts that require +programs from the `iproute2` package. + +Configuration files are typically stored in `/etc/netcfg/` (depending on +configure options). + +Please note that the loopback device is treated specially and not included in +any of the network configuration outlined below. The loopback device is brought +up and configured by a dedicated service long before the network configuration +is done. + + +## Interface Renaming + +If the `ifrename` service is enabled (it is disabled by default), network +interfaces are renamed based on a rule set stored in the file `ifrename`. +The file contains comma separated shell globing patterns for the current +interface name, MAC address and a prefix for the new interface name. + +For each network interface, rules are processed top to bottom. If the first two +globing patterns apply, the interface is renamed. Interfaces with the same +prefix are sorted by mac address and a running index is appended to the prefix. + +If none of the rules apply, the interface name is left unchanged. + + +The intent is, to provide a way to configure persistent, deterministic names for +at least all network interfaces that are permanently installed on a board. + +Extension cards or external network adapters should be given a different prefix +to avoid changes in the order as they come and go. + + +## Interface Configuration + +After interface renaming, for each network interface, the configuration path is +scanned for files with the same name as the interface. + +Each successfully found configuration file is processed line by line, top to +bottom. Each line may contain a keyword, followed by multiple arguments. + +The following keywords can be used to add IPv4 or IPv6 network addresses to +an interface: + + * address + * addr + * ip + * ip6 + * ipv6 + +Those commands are expected to be followed by an IPv4 or IPv6 address and +network mask. + + +Furthermore, the following commands can be used for configuring interface +parameters: + + * `arp {on|off}` + * `multicast {on|off}` + * `mtu ` + * `offload [rx {on|off}] [tx {on|off}] [sg {on|off}] [tso {on|off}]` + * `offload [gso {on|off}] [gro {on|off}] [lro {on|off}] [rxvlan {on|off}]` + * `offload [txvlan {on|off}] [ntuple {on|off}] [rxhash {on|off}]` + * `offload [ufo {on|off}]` + + +## Route Configuration + +After interface configuration is done, routes and rules are restored from a +file named `routes` in the same configuration path. + +The file may contain lines starting with `route` or `rule`. Everything that +follows is passed on to `ip route add` or `ip rule add` respectively. + + +## Net Filter Tables + + +An additional service is provided that restores the nft rule set from +`/etc/nftables.rules`. diff --git a/docs/services.md b/docs/services.md index 223cfb5..de0bd21 100644 --- a/docs/services.md +++ b/docs/services.md @@ -1,84 +1,31 @@ # Service Files -Services that can be started and managed by init are described by service -description files stored in `/usr/share/init`. +The init process reads service descriptions from `/etc/init.d` which usually +contains symlinks to the actual service files which can be conveniently removed +or added to disable or enable services. -The init process actually reads from `/etc/init.d` which contains symlinks to -the actual service files. +Default services provided by this package are installed in `/usr/share/init`, +i.e. this is where the symlinks point to. + + +Note that the actual locations may be different, depending on the configure +flags used. -Enabling a service means adding a symlink, disabling means removing a symlink. Service descriptions can be parameterized. The arguments are extracted from the name of the symlink. Currently only 1 parameter is supported. The argument value is separated from the service name by an '@' character in the symlink name. +The file name of the sysmlink, excluding any parameters, is accepted as the +canonical name of a service and used when referring to it via command line +utilities or when injecting dependencies from a service file. -Below is an annotated example for a simple, service description for a -generic, parameterized agetty service: +## Syntax - # - # The text that init should print out when the status of the - # service changes. - # - # The '%0' is replaced with the first argument extracted from the - # symlink name. - # - description "agetty on %0" - - # - # How to run the service. 'respawn' means restart the service when it - # terminates, 'once' means run it only once and continue with other - # services in the mean while, 'wait' means run it once, but block until - # it exits. - # - type respawn - - # - # When to start the service. 'boot' means when booting the system. Other - # options are 'reboot', 'shutdown' and 'ctrlaltdel'. The system always - # starts into the 'boot' target and then later transitions to one of the - # others. - # - target boot - - # - # A list of service names that must be started before this service can - # be run, i.e. this services needs to be started after those. - # - # This can only refer to generic names, not specific instances. For - # instance, you can say "after getty" to make sure a service comes up after - # all gettys are started, but you cannot specify "after agetty@tty1". - # - # Similar to 'after', there is also a 'before' keyword for specifying - # dependencies. - # - after sysinit - - # - # The 'tty' directive specifies a file to which all I/O of the process is - # redirected. The specified device file is used as a controlling tty for - # the process and a new session is created with the service process as - # session leader. - # - # In this example, we derive the controlling tty from the service - # description argument. - # - tty "/dev/%0" - - # - # The 'exec' directive specifies the command to execute in order to start - # the service. See in the example below on how to run multiple commands. - # - # Again we use the argument to specify what terminal our getty - # should run on. - # - exec agetty %0 linux - -As can be seen in this simple example, each line in a service description is -made up of a keyword, followed by one or more arguments and terminated by a -line break. +Each line in a service description is made up of a keyword, followed by one +or more arguments and terminated by a line break. Blank lines are ignored and shell-style comments can be used. @@ -92,6 +39,115 @@ done using a '%' sign, followed by the argument index. A '%' sign can be escaped by writing '%%'. +## Targets and Types + +Service files specify a *target* which is basically like a SystemV runlevel +and can be one of the following: + +* boot +* reboot +* shutdown + +After parsing the configuration files, the init process starts running the +services for the `boot` target in a topological order as determined by their +dependencies. + +Services can be of one of the following *types*: + +* wait +* once +* respawn + +Services of type `wait` are started exactly once and the init process waits +until they terminate before continuing with other services. + +The type `once` also only runs services once, but immediately continues +starting other services in the mean time without waiting. The init process +only waits for `once` types when transitioning to another target. + +Services of type `respawn` also don't stall the init process and are re-started +whenever they terminate. + +The keyword `limit` can be used a after `respawn` to specify how often a service +may be restarted before giving up. + + +## Dependencies + +A service description file can specify dependencies using the keywords `after` +and `before`, each followed by a space separated list of service names. + +The init program executes a service after all the services specified by the +`after` keyword have been started (type once or respawn) or have been completed +(type wait). + +The `before` keyword injects dependencies in reverse, i.e. all services +specified after the `before` keyword are only executed after the service in +question has been started. + +If a service specified by `after` or `before` does not exist, it is simply +ignored. This can occur for instance if the specified service is not enabled +at all in the current configuration. + + +## Running Services + +If a service contains an `exec` line, the init process attempts to run it +using the `runsvc` helper program that sets up the environment, attempts to +execute the specified command line and passes the exit status back to the init +process. + +If multiple exec lines are specified, `runsvc` executes them sequentially and +stops if any one returns a non-zero exit status. + +The environment variables visible to the service processes are read +from `/etc/initd.env`. + +If the service description contains a `tty` field, the specified device file +is opened by runsvc and standard I/O is redirected to it and a new session +is created. The keyword `truncate` can be used to make `runsvc` truncate the +file to zero size first. + +For convenience, multiple exec lines can be wrapped into braces, as can be +seen in one of the examples below. + + +## Example + +Below is an annotated example for a simple, service description for a +generic, parameterized getty service: + + # + # The text that init should print out when the status of the + # service changes. + # + # The '%0' is replaced with the first argument extracted from the + # symlink name. + # + description "agetty on %0" + + # Restart the getty when it terminates. + type respawn + + # We want to spawn gettys when booting the system + target boot + + # Only run this service after the 'sysinit' service is done + after sysinit + + # + # Redirect all I/O of the process to this file. The specified device file + # is used as a controlling tty for the process and a new session is created + # with the service process as session leader. + # + # In this example, we derive the controlling tty from the service + # description argument. + # + tty "/dev/%0" + + # In order to run the service, simply fire up the agetty program + exec agetty %0 linux + If a service should sequentially run multiple commands, they can be grouped inside braces as can be seen in the following, abbreviated example: @@ -107,4 +163,3 @@ inside braces as can be seen in the following, abbreviated example: mkdir /var/tmp -m 0755 mount --bind /cfg/preserve/var_lib /var/lib } - diff --git a/docs/usyslogd.md b/docs/usyslogd.md new file mode 100644 index 0000000..96f5755 --- /dev/null +++ b/docs/usyslogd.md @@ -0,0 +1,94 @@ +# Syslogd Implementation + +A tiny syslogd implementation `usyslogd` is provided as part of this package. + +It opens a socket in `/dev/log`, processes syslog messages and forwards the +parsed message to a modular backend interface. + +Currently, there is only one implementation of the backend interface that dumps +the log messages into files in the processes working directory (by default +`/var/log`). + +A simple log rotation scheme has been implemented. + + +## Security Considerations + +By default, the daemon switches its working directory to `/var/log`. The +directory is created if it doesn't exist and the daemon always tries to +change its mode to one that doesn't allow other users (except group members) +to access the directory. + +If told to so on the command line, the daemon chroots to the log directory. + +By default, the daemon then tries to drop privileges by switching to user and +group named `syslogd` if they exist (any other user or group can be specified +on the command line; doing so causes syslogd to fail if they don't exist). + + +On a system that hosts accounts for multiple users that may be more or less +trusted, one may consider only giving system services access to the syslog +socket and not allowing regular users. Otherwise, a user may flood the syslog +daemon with messages, possibly leading to resource starvation, or (in the case +of size limited log rotation outlined below) to the loss of otherwise critical +log messages. Since this is not the primary target of the Pygos system, such +a mechanism is not yet implemented. + +In case of a system where only daemons are running, the above mentioned +security measure is useless. If a remote attacker manages to get regular user +privileges, you already have a different, much greater problem. Also, a remote +attacker would have to compromise a local daemon that already has special +access to the syslog socket, which is again your least concern in this +scenario. + + +## Logrotation + +The backend can be configured to do log rotation in a continuous fashion (i.e. +in a way that log messages aren't lost), or in a way where it drops old +messages. Furthermore, the backend can be configured to automatically do a log +rotation if a certain size threshold is hit. + +If the `usyslogd` receives a `SIGHUP`, it tells the backend to do log rotation. + +In the case of the size threshold, the backend is expected to do the rotation +on its own if the predetermined limit is hit. + + +## File Based Backend + +The file based backend writes log messages to files in the current working +directory (by default `/var/log`), named either after the ident string (if +specified) or the facility name. + +Log messages are prefixed with an ISO 8601 time stamp, optionally the facility +name (unless part of the file name), the log level and the senders PID. Each +of those fields is enclosed in brackets. + +Log rotation in a continuous fashion means renaming the existing log file to +one suffixed with the current time stamp. Overwriting old messages renaming +the log file by appending a constant `.1` suffix. + + +## Default Configuration + +The default service configuration limits the log file size to 8 KiB and +configures the daemon to overwrite old messages when rotating log files, +effectively limiting the amount of log data to 16 KiB per source or facility. + +The intended use case in the Pygos system is logging to a ramdisk without +exhausting available memory. + + +## Possible Future Directions + +In the near term future, the daemon probably requires more fine grained control +over logging such as setting a minimum log level or a way to configure limits +per facility or service. + +In the medium term future, extended resource control using c-groups might be +a possibility. + +Future directions may include adding other backends, such as forwarding the +log messages to a central server, for instance using syslog over UDP/TCP or +using the front end of some time series database.